Share the post "Australia Banned Teens from Social Media. So Why Are They Still There?"

How old were you when you opened your first social media account? And did anyone ever check? For me the answers are 14 and no. There was just a note saying you had to be a certain age. Nobody asked for proof.
Australia wanted to change exactly that. Since December 2025 under-16s are no longer allowed on TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat or YouTube. Within weeks around 4.7 million accounts were removed or restricted. It sounds like a success. Yet six months later 92% of 14- and 15-year-olds were still using a banned platform every week. So what did the law really change?
Maybe the more uncomfortable question is this one. What if the problem was never the teenagers but the companies we trusted to keep them out? With the UK, Greece and the EU preparing similar rules, Europe will need an answer soon. In this post I argue that the ban is not failing because teens are clever hackers. It is failing because the platforms that are supposed to enforce it profit from the very users they are supposed to remove.
A good idea on paper
The concerns behind the ban are real. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen pointed out that young Europeans spend four to six hours a day on screens. She described the current situation as giving “big tech unrestricted access to our children”. Australia also started with confidence. After the first numbers came in, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant said “I am very pleased with these preliminary results”.
What the data actually shows
The optimism did not last long. In its own three-month review the regulator admitted that “many children aged under 16 still have their accounts or can create new accounts”. A study in the British Medical Journal found that more than 85% of under-16s were still using social media three months after the ban. Researchers from the National Bureau of Economic Research, who found the 92% figure, also reported that 75% of teens said getting around the rules was easy.
The most interesting detail is how teens got around it. Many people expected them to hide behind VPNs, but VPN use was actually rare. Among children who kept their accounts, the most common reason was simply that the platform had never asked them to verify their age. That sounds exactly like my own experience at 14. Account ownership fell from 52.4% to 42.1% while actual use barely moved.
Why this is a management problem
From a business perspective the logic is simple. The law asks Meta, TikTok and Snapchat to remove their own future customers. Teenagers build the habits and the social networks that keep a platform valuable for years. The NBER researchers found that as long as popular teens stay online, the platforms stay attractive and not using them becomes socially costly for everyone else. Removing users is expensive and reduces engagement, while the maximum fine of A$49.5 million is a small risk for a company the size of Meta. Strict enforcement simply goes against the platforms’ own interests.
Meta’s response shows this clearly. Instead of improving its own checks it argues that there should be “a single reliable age signal” at the operating system or app store level. In other words, Apple and Google should do the checking and carry the cost. From Meta’s point of view that is a smart strategic move.
The ban also has side effects. The share of parents who did not know whether their child had used social media rose from 23% to 33%. Professor Kathryn Modecki from the University of Western Australia warned that “these workarounds may mean kids are online with even less regulation and oversight”.
My view
I think Australia’s experience shows that a ban that depends on the platforms to enforce it was set up to fail. Looking back at my own first Instagram account, the problem was never a missing law. It was a missing check. If Europe wants to copy the ban, three things need to change. First, fines should depend on revenue as under the GDPR, so ignoring the rules is no longer cheaper than following them. Second, age checks should happen once at the device level instead of separately in every app. Third, and most importantly, regulators should go after the design features that make platforms addictive, such as infinite scrolling and autoplay. In my opinion the success of a ban should not be measured by the number of deleted accounts but by whether teenagers are actually safer online. By that measure Australia is not there yet.
Would you support a ban like this in your country or is it the wrong tool?
References
- https://www.globaldatinginsights.com/featured/eu-advances-plans-for-tighter-social-media-restrictions-on-teens/
- https://euronews.com/next/2026/01/15/australia-under-16-social-media-ban-how-is-it-going-one-month-since-law-took-effect
- https://www.techpolicy.press/early-lessons-from-australias-teen-social-media-ban-for-the-rest-of-the-world/
- https://theconversation.com/85-of-kids-are-still-using-social-media-despite-ban-but-we-need-a-new-measure-to-judge-its-success-285946
- https://www.cato.org/research-briefs-economic-policy/australias-social-media-ban-did-not-change-norms
- https://www.technology.org/2026/10/20/teen-social-media-ban-australia-data-eu-kids-act/
- https://thenextweb.com/news/australia-social-media-ban-meta-age-signal-app-store
- https://euronews.com/next/2026/01/29/australias-under-16-social-media-ban-how-children-are-already-finding-ways-around-it
AI use disclosure; Engine used: Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic)
–Source Gathering & Fact-Checking:
“Search the web for recent articles and reliable sources regarding Australia’s social media ban for under-16s and its effects on teenagers and platforms. Gather key facts, data points, and cross-check them to ensure accuracy.”
–Grammar & Spelling Corrections:
“Check this text for spelling and grammar mistakes, remove filler words, and make longer sentences shorter. Do not change the meaning of the sentence.”
–Image Generation & Prompting:
“Create a detailed image prompt for an AI image generator that fits the following text: Australia banned teens from social media, but most of them are still online. The style should be modern, clean, and professional for a tech blog.”