Picture telling your AI assistant: “order milk and toilet paper.” At Walmart, the agent will soon be allowed to do it. At Amazon, it walks straight into a wall. Within about a month, America’s two retail giants gave opposite answers to one question: who owns the moment a customer decides to buy? I won’t crown a winner. I think each company picked the answer that fits where it stands, and copying the other would be a mistake.
What actually happened
In September, Amazon started blocking Meta’s Muse agent from shopping for users on Amazon.com. On 21 October, Walmart went the other way and announced three things:
- Agent Gateway: a direct connection (built on MCP) that lets agents search Walmart’s inventory and buy.
- Agent Profiles: every agent gets its own profile inside your account. You approve each purchase or set a spending limit (Walmart’s examples are $50, $100 and $200).
- Terms for AI agents: approval is on by default, no card details, nothing beyond what the shopper asked for. Rule breakers get blocked.
Walmart already works with Muse, ChatGPT and Gemini. Best line of the announcement: “We price products, not people.”
Why the wall makes sense for Amazon
Amazon’s official line is about its rules: shopping agents must identify themselves as bots, and Amazon says Muse didn’t. But I’d follow the money. Amazon made $19.6 billion from advertising in Q3 2026 alone, up 12% year on year. A big chunk of that comes from brands paying to show up at the top of your search results.
An AI agent doesn’t scroll, and a “Sponsored” badge doesn’t tempt it. It just picks. If agents do the shopping, the paid slot loses its audience. Data works the same way: when an agent shops for you, Amazon’s clicks happen somewhere else. So Amazon wants agentic shopping to happen inside its own store and its own AI assistant, where it controls the ranking and the ads.
When you’re the online leader with a huge ad business and customer data to protect, a closed gate is a sensible default. The law is a bit wobbly, though. Amazon sued Perplexity over its Comet assistant shopping through Amazon accounts. In March 2026 a district court gave Amazon a preliminary injunction. In August the Ninth Circuit vacated it: “it was the user who ‘accessed’ Amazon’s computers.” It’s an early ruling and the contract claims are still open, but the wall is less solid than Amazon hoped.
Why the door makes sense for Walmart
Open doesn’t mean uncontrolled. Walmart decides who gets in, what they see (no card numbers) and how much they can spend. The customer account stays with Walmart. It’s a classic platform move: you don’t own every screen, but you own the rules.
Walmart is the challenger online. It has less to lose when agents skip its ad slots and more to gain from being the store those agents find easy. Walmart sells ads too, so it is betting that reach beats ad margin. Agent Profiles were promised “in the next month.” Announcing is easy. Shipping is harder.
Don’t swallow the forecast whole
Morgan Stanley estimates agents could handle about 10% of US online retail by 2030, up to 20% in the optimistic case: $190 to $385 billion in spending. I’m not buying it as a given.
First, that range is huge. When the top end is double the bottom end, the honest summary is “we don’t know.” It also dates from late 2025, before Amazon blocked Muse or Walmart opened up.
Second, Morgan Stanley also estimated that roughly 23% of Americans had bought something through AI in the past month. That’s the bank’s own estimate, worked out from adoption rates, not a count of actual shoppers. And it clashes with Andy Jassy saying outside agents aren’t meaningfully affecting the ad business, because “few customers are doing much shopping this way yet.” Jassy runs the company with the wall, so he’s not neutral either. Still, I find him more believable for today. If nearly a quarter of Americans shopped through AI every month, I’d expect Amazon’s ad business to feel it. It still grew 12%.
My opinion, not a fact: forecasts from banks tend to lean optimistic about hot trends. If the forecast is too high, Amazon’s wall is less risky for longer.
My take
This is the textbook walled garden vs open platform fight, live. Which is smarter? It depends where you start. Amazon is protecting the business model it already has: ads and data, earned inside its own interface. Walmart is preparing for the interface it expects, where customers talk to ChatGPT or Gemini instead of opening a store’s app, and as the challenger it can afford the experiment. Platform strategy follows market position. If Walmart copied the wall, it would be guarding a castle it doesn’t have yet. If Amazon copied the door, it would be putting its ad business at risk to chase a trend Jassy says hasn’t arrived.
What would change my mind:
- Agent shopping grows fast, and Amazon’s own numbers start to show it. Then the wall gets riskier.
- Amazon later opens a paid “approved agents only” entrance. That’s pure speculation, but it would mean even the leader needed a door, just with a ticket booth.
Until then, wall for the leader, door for the challenger. Both are right, and the mistake would be swapping them.
Sources
- https://corporate.walmart.com/news/2026/10/Making-It-Possible-for-Agents-to-Shop-on-Behalf-of-Customers
- https://siliconangle.com/2026/09/21/amazon-blocks-metas-muse-agent-from-shopping-on-users-behalf/
- https://www.marketingdive.com/news/amazons-ad-revenue-growth-decelerates-due-to-prime-day-tweaks/873302/
- https://www.morganstanley.com/insights/articles/agentic-commerce-market-impact-outlook
- https://www.cooley.com/news/insight/2026/2026-08-06-ninth-circuit-rules-on-ai-agent-access-to-third-party-websites-under-cfaa
AI engine used: Claude Sonnet (Anthropic)
Prompts used:
- “Suggest 5 recent tech news topics I could write a Management in E-economy blog post about, from new gadgets to AI and platforms, as long as there’s something to debate.” I picked Amazon blocking AI shopping agents while Walmart lets them in.
- “Research it using only primary sources and established news outlets: what each company announced, the key numbers, the Amazon vs Perplexity case, and who argues for and against each approach.”
- “Write a casual first-person blog post on whether Amazon’s wall or Walmart’s open door is the better strategy. I think neither is simply smarter, it depends where each company starts: Amazon is the leader protecting a huge ad business, Walmart is the challenger online with less to lose. Don’t just repeat the sources, question the ones that sound too optimistic. Around 900 words, 5 sources.”
- “Fact-check every number, date, quote and link, and point out any weak arguments.”